506647270581844
top of page

Understanding Procurement Fraud Risk Assessment: A Comprehensive Guide

Updated: Aug 29, 2023

Supplier fraud can be a costly and damaging problem for businesses. This guide provides a step-by-step approach to assess and managing supplier fraud risk.

Procurement fraud risk
Risk is just an expensive substitute for information

In today's rapidly changing business landscape, supplier fraud risk assessment has become an essential part of any organization's risk management strategy. The COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted the importance of assessing supplier risks and creating contingency plans to mitigate potential disruptions to the supply chain and a response against procurement fraud is no different.


Businesses need to be proactive in identifying potential risks that could impact their operations and take necessary steps to minimize the impact of these risks. Supplier risk assessment is critical for ensuring business continuity, maintaining customer satisfaction, and minimizing financial losses.


In this article, we will explore the importance of supplier fraud risk assessment as part of an onboarding risk assessment process, the benefits it offers, and how it can be implemented effectively to mitigate potential business disruptions. Whether you are a small business owner or a multinational corporation, understanding the importance of supplier fraud risk assessment is crucial to ensuring the long-term success of your business.


Don't view procurement fraud risk mitigation as an expense, but rather as a strategic investment that pays off in the form of long-term stability and trust

Understanding the impact of supplier disruptions

Supplier disruptions can have a significant impact on a company's operations, finances, and reputation. For example, if a company's primary supplier experiences a production delay due to natural disasters, the company may not be able to meet its customers' demands, resulting in lost sales and potential customer dissatisfaction.


Additionally, supplier disruptions can cause reputational damage if the company is unable to deliver on its promises to its customers. In some cases, supplier disruptions can also lead to financial losses due to contractual penalties or the cost of sourcing alternative suppliers.


Therefore, it is essential for organisations to understand the impact of supplier disruptions and take necessary steps to mitigate the risks. This is where supplier risk assessment comes in.

BENEFITS OF RISK ASSESSMENT

Conducting supplier risk assessment offers several benefits to organisations. Firstly, it helps companies identify potential risks that could impact their operations, finances, and reputation. This information allows companies to create contingency plans and mitigate the risks before they occur.


Secondly, supplier risk assessment provides companies with an opportunity to review their supply chain and identify areas for improvement. This can lead to more efficient and effective supply chain management. Thirdly, supplier risk assessments can help companies build stronger relationships with their suppliers.



By communicating and collaborating on risk management strategies, companies and suppliers can work together to minimise potential disruptions and build trust.


Key components of a supplier risk assessment

The key components of a supplier risk assessment include:


1. Supplier identification and categorization

The first step in conducting a supplier risk assessment is to identify and categorize suppliers based on their importance to the company's operations. For example, primary suppliers who provide critical goods or services are considered high-risk, while secondary suppliers who provide non-critical goods or services are considered low-risk.


2. Risk identification and evaluation

The next step is to identify and evaluate the potential risks associated with each supplier. This includes assessing risks such as financial stability, production capacity, quality control, and geographic location. The evaluation process should be based on both qualitative and quantitative data.


3. Supplier due diligence

Before engaging with a supplier, it is important to conduct background checks to ensure that they are a legitimate business. This can include:

  1. Checking their registration with relevant authorities, verifying executive and shareholder information, reviewing business financial statements, and verifying their physical address.

  2. Assess their reputation by researching the supplier's reputation in the industry and among their customers. Look for reviews and feedback from previous clients to determine if they have a history of fraudulent behaviour or unethical practices.

  3. Evaluate their internal controls to determine if they have adequate measures in place to prevent fraud. This can include reviewing their policies and procedures, assessing their risk management practices, and evaluating their internal audit function.

  4. Review their financial statements to determine if there are any red flags or inconsistencies that may indicate fraudulent activity. Look for unusual transactions, discrepancies in financial reporting, or unexplained changes in financial performance.

  5. Conduct on-site visits to the supplier's facilities to assess their operations and verify their physical presence. This can include reviewing their inventory, observing their production processes, and assessing their quality control measures.

  6. Monitoring of performance to identify any potential fraud risks. This can include reviewing their invoices and payment records, conducting periodic audits, and maintaining open communication with the supplier.

  7. Verifying supplier fraud prevention programme to ensure that they minimise passing on their fraud risk. This might include the leadership message, policies and procedures for identifying and mitigating fraud risks. This can include training employees on fraud prevention, establishing reporting mechanisms for suspicious activity, and conducting regular risk assessments.

4. Risk mitigation and contingency planning

Once the risks have been identified and evaluated, the next step is to develop a risk mitigation and contingency plan where a fraud response is necessary. This includes identifying strategies to minimize potential disruptions and creating a plan to manage the risks if they do occur. Contingency plans should include alternative suppliers, safety stock, and communication protocols.


5. How to identify and evaluate supplier risks

Identifying and evaluating supplier risks requires gathering both internal and external data. Internal data includes historical data on supplier performance, financial stability, and quality control. External data includes industry trends, news reports, and geopolitical events. The evaluation process should consider both the likelihood and potential impact of each risk.


6. Mitigating supplier risks through contingency planning

Contingency planning is a critical component of supplier risk management that involves identifying potential disruptions and creating a plan to manage the risks if they occur. This includes identifying alternative suppliers, safety stock, and communication protocols. Communication is a crucial aspect of response planning as it allows companies to quickly respond to disruptions and minimize their impact.


BEST PRACTICES FOR SUPPLIER RISK ASSESSMENT

To conduct effective supplier risk assessments, organizations should follow these best practices:


A. Risk management team

Create a dedicated team responsible for managing supplier risks. This team should include representatives from different departments, such as procurement, supply chain, and finance.


B. Use a risk assessment framework

Use of a risk assessment framework to evaluate suppliers consistently. The framework should include both qualitative and quantitative data.


C. Conduct regular reviews

Conducting regular reviews of supplier risks to ensure that the risk assessment is up to date and relevant. This is particularly applicable within projects with high volumes of procurement, invoicing and resources.


D. Build strong relationships with suppliers

Build strong relationships with suppliers by communicating and collaborating on risk management strategies. This can help build trust and minimize potential disruptions where a root cause of any identified risk is clearly resolved and risk mitigated.


Supplier risk assessment tools and software

Several tools and software are available to help organisations conduct supplier risk assessments. These tools include risk assessment frameworks, supplier scorecards, and risk management software. These tools can help streamline the risk assessment process and provide companies with valuable insights into their supply chain.


Call to action for implementing supplier risk assessment

Supplier risk assessment is critical for ensuring business continuity, maintaining customer satisfaction, and minimizing financial losses. By conducting regular risk assessments and implementing contingency plans that include fraud risk mitigation, organisations can minimise the impact of supplier disruptions and build stronger relationships with their suppliers. If you have not yet implemented supplier risk assessment in your business, you may have unknown fraud risk and significant financial loss.



Do you want to work with us?

Book a Strategy Call with us to see how we can positively impact your risk approach












Be the first to receive our latest articles




bottom of page